Are you in the market for a new chainsaw but unsure which model to choose? The Echo CS 310 and Stihl MS 170 are two of the most popular lightweight chainsaws available, and for good reason.
Both offer powerful engines and impressive cutting abilities, making them ideal for home and farm use. But which one comes out on top in the Echo CS 310 vs Stihl MS 170 showdown?
In this article, we will compare these two chainsaws in detail, examining their engine size, power, features, design, price, and warranty terms.
By the end, you’ll have a clear understanding of the differences between these models and which one is right for your needs.
So, let’s dive in and find out which chainsaw reigns supreme.
- Echo CS 310 has a larger engine size and power than Stihl MS 170, but Stihl has better fuel efficiency and cutting capacity.
- Both chainsaws can accommodate 12, 14, and 16-inch bars with chains having a 3/8 pitch.
- Echo CS 310 has an automatic clutch-driven oiler and dual-post chain brake, while Stihl MS 170 features an ematic lubrication system that delivers oil specifically to the saw chain.
- Echo CS 310 is generally cheaper and has a longer warranty than Stihl MS 170, but some customers have reported issues with Stihl’s oiling system. Buyers should consider their needs and budget when choosing between them.
Engine and Power
The engine size and power are important factors to compare between Echo CS 310 and Stihl MS 170. Echo CS 310 features a 30.5cc engine with 1.4 horsepower, while Stihl MS 170 has a 30.1cc engine with a Stihl-2-Mix engine and intellicarb compensating carburetor.
Both chainsaws have similar engine sizes and horsepower, but Stihl MS 170’s Stihl-2-Mix engine and intellicarb compensating carburetor provide better fuel efficiency and cutting capacity.
Fuel efficiency is crucial for chainsaw users, as it determines the amount of fuel needed per use and the overall operating cost. Stihl MS 170’s Stihl-2-Mix engine and intellicarb compensating carburetor help with fuel efficiency, allowing users to save on fuel costs.
Additionally, cutting capacity is an important factor to consider, as it determines the thickness of branches that a chainsaw can cut through.
While both chainsaws have similar engine sizes and horsepower, Stihl MS 170’s features allow for a better cutting capacity than Echo CS 310.
Features and Design
In terms of design and features, both chainsaws share similarities such as their ability to accommodate 12, 14, and 16-inch bars with chains having a 3/8 pitch.
However, the Stihl MS 170 sets itself apart with its intellicarb compensating carburetor. This component enables a more precise fuel-to-air ratio, resulting in improved fuel efficiency.
The Echo CS 310, on the other hand, boasts an automatic clutch-driven oiler and dual-post chain brake, further enhancing its usability.
Both chainsaws also come equipped with vibration-reduction systems, reducing the risk of user fatigue and injury.
When comparing the lubrication systems of each chainsaw, the Stihl MS 170’s ematic lubrication system stands out.
This system delivers oil specifically to the saw chain, resulting in less oil consumption and an overall longer lifespan for the chain.
The Echo CS 310, on the other hand, features a top-mounted air filter and side access chain tensioning, making maintenance and cleaning easier for the user.
Despite their differences, both chainsaws offer similar levels of functionality and usability, making them popular choices for home and farm tasks.
Ultimately, the choice between the two will come down to personal preference and specific needs.
Price and Warranty
Price and warranty are important factors to consider when comparing Echo CS 310 and Stihl MS 170 chainsaws. Echo CS 310 is generally cheaper than Stihl MS 170, making it a popular choice for those on a budget.
However, it’s important to note that the lower price point does not necessarily mean lower quality.
Echo offers a five-year consumer warranty and a one-year commercial warranty, which is better than the two-year consumer warranty and one-year commercial warranty offered by Stihl.
In terms of durability comparison, customer reviews indicate that both chainsaws are reliable and long-lasting. However, some customers have reported issues with the Stihl MS 170’s oiling system, which can cause the chain to become dry and damage the saw.
On the other hand, the Echo CS 310 has received praise for its efficient oiling system, which keeps the chain lubricated and running smoothly.
Ultimately, buyers should consider their needs and budget when deciding between these two chainsaws.